The QB position [Archive] - Wildcat Nation Forums - Kentucky Wildcat Discussion and News

PDA

View Full Version : The QB position


jwade
04-19-2008, 11:15 PM
There's been, understandably, a lot of discussion and apprehension over who will ultimately lead the team in the fall. While I share some of those concerns, I would also offer the following food for thought.

Of the past eleven seasons (1997-2007, inclusive) nine of them have been led by Couch (97-98), Lorenzen (00-03) and Woodson (05-07). These are three of the greatest QB's, and arguably the three greatest QB's, in the history of UK football. Couch had an NFL career, Lorenzen is in the NFL, and Woodson seems likely. On top of that, Bonner threw for over 3200 yards in 99.

The point is this: we've enjoyed an embarrassment of riches at the QB position in recent history and have become spoiled by the sheer talent we've seen on the field. Other teams, successful teams, don't have an NFL-caliber QB year after year after year. It's unrealistic to think that we will. And yet, those teams are successful and there's no reason to think we can't be just as successful.

This team is moving slowly, inexorably, toward playing what RV calls "big boy" football. Solid defense, solid running game, solid special teams - and solid passing game. No longer will the passing game be required to carry a disproportionate share of the load in order to achieve success. Those days are coming to an end.

Following the scrimmage a week or so ago, Coach Brooks said something to the effect of "we need to pass well - not necessarily great." RV made a similar observation that same day, saying in effect this offense needs the threat of the long ball in order to be successful. Both statements dovetail with the point I'm trying to make - that we're becoming a more balanced team less dependent upon any single unit.

That's not to say we don't need good QB play - of course we do, just as we need good play from all other positions. It simply means we're becoming less dependent upon the QB to carry the load. This is a good thing, and part of our natural evolution.

So, don't fret too much if Pulley and Hartline don't develop into the next Couch/Lorenzen/Woodson. They don't have to. They, along with the WR corps, simply need to develop into an efficient unit that consistently completes the short and medium range passes, maximizes yards-after-catch, and completes the occasional long ball to keep the opponent's safeties honest. If our offensive skill players can do that, this offense and this team will be just fine.


Jim

matt colvin
04-19-2008, 11:19 PM
Jim, to be honest, that's just what I needed to read after watching today's scrimmage. Thank you very much!

Brian McCat
04-19-2008, 11:23 PM
Jim makes a great point about the big 3, but don't forget that the other 2 quarterbacks were very successful. Shane Boyd is still in the NFL, and Bonner transferred from UK, eventually winning the Div I-AA equivalent of the Heisman 2 years in a row.

Like he says, we don't need all-SEC quarterbacking, just solid passing and leadership. We're becoming balanced enough as a team that we don't need a savior at the QB position.

bellbrass
04-19-2008, 11:32 PM
I agree that we've had it pretty good here at QB for awhile. I remember the days when QB was our sore spot. We haven't had that in awhile. That being said, Hartline and Pulley (and Fidler) are still talented guys. Any one of them could, with time, develop into a great QB.

UKGrad87
04-20-2008, 12:23 AM
Great post, Jim. Case in point: Neither Matt Flynn nor Ryan Perrilloux were great QBs last year by most quantifiable measures (passing offense ranked 58th nationally), yet LSU did ok.

UedK
04-20-2008, 07:06 AM
After witnessing yesterday's game I am happy with the QB development and am not at all displeased with the fact that we have no clear winner in the QB competition. Both showed the ability to lead the offense under pressure and with some success.

Both drives at the end of the game showed me a lot. With the game on the line the fight each side exhibited in wanting the victory said a lot about this team.

Pulley's last TD for the winning 17 yard run was the perfect result for that drive. And Hartline's guts and determination to get his squad into field goal position with the clock ticking down made me realize that he too can lead this team if called upon. For those that were not there during the Hartline drive. Joker's offense failed to call a critical time out that could have extended the game. When the TO was finally called you could see Brooks getting all over Joker about the situation. A true case of the understudy getting a little lesson from the man.

I also like RV's statement about 'Big Boy Football'. Reminds me of some of the Auburn teams that we could never hang with, especially the running game combined with a serviceable quarterback and a very deep and talented offensive line. I remember Auburn sending great back after great back at us until finally in the later stages of the game we just were worn down. I see us having that kind of game this fall.

poodoo
04-20-2008, 04:03 PM
Great posts with valid points, Jim and UedK. For me, personally, I especially loved how both quarterbacks performed under pressure. As always, I can hardly wait for the season to begin. :icon_biggrin: